Check out my 1:1 training options, workshops, and classes!

Self-control or owner control? There's a difference.

Self-control or owner control? There's a difference.

You may have heard of the famous marshmallow experiment. Children were given a choice: eat one marshmallow immediately or wait until the researcher returned and receive two instead.


It was an experiment exploring delayed gratification – the ability to resist an immediate reward in favour of something better later.


It's an interesting concept when we think about our dogs, because how often do we expect them to control their impulses? To wait, resist temptation, manage their excitement or make a different choice when something they really want is right in front of them?


But I think there's an important distinction we sometimes overlook. Are we actually teaching our dogs self-control, or are we simply controlling them ourselves?


Think about how much of our dogs' everyday lives we manage. We tell them when to sit, when to wait, when to stop, when to move and when they're allowed to do something. We anticipate their behaviour and step in before they've had much opportunity to work things out for themselves.


There's nothing inherently wrong with giving dogs guidance, of course, but if we're constantly managing every situation, when do they get the opportunity to learn to manage their own impulses?


For me, teaching self-control means being prepared to step back a little. It means being more patient, giving our dogs me to think and allowing them to discover that their own behaviour can influence what happens next.


Take putting the lead on, for example. How many of us have a dog who gets terribly excited when the lead appears? Perhaps they bounce around, jump up or grab at it. Our usual response might be to ask them to sit, repeat the instruction and wait until they eventually comply.


What if we simply held the lead and waited?


No repeated instructions, no demands for a sit. Just a little patience. When the dog offers an appropriate behaviour, perhaps four feet on the floor or a moment of calm, we put the lead on. The lead itself becomes the reward, followed by the much bigger reward of going out for a walk.


We're allowing the dog to discover that waiting and managing their excitement makes something they want happen. We're not doing all the thinking for them.


And this becomes particularly interesting when we look at reactive dogs.


Teaching a reactive dog to manage their impulses is absolutely possible, but it often takes considerably longer. We cannot expect a dog who is worried, frightened or frustrated by the sight of another dog to suddenly make sensible decisions just because we'd like them to.


Instead, we need to give them space and time. Watching another dog from a comfortable distance, having the opportunity to observe what's happening without being pressured to approach or react, and gradually learning that they don't need to do anything about it.


Sometimes the most valuable thing we can do is stand still, keep a comfortable distance and let our dog watch. We don't need to constantly distract them, ask for eye contact or tell them what to do. We need to give them the opportunity to process what they're seeing and learn from the experience.


This isn't about leaving a dog to struggle or expecting them to cope with something they're not ready for. It's about finding the distance and circumstances where they can observe, think and gradually develop more confidence in their own decisions.


Perhaps the biggest challenge in teaching self-control is actually learning to control ourselves. To stop anticipating, directing and managing every little thing our dogs do. To become comfortable with waiting and allowing them the time they need to work things out.


We don't need to make every decision for our dogs. Sometimes we need to give them the opportunity to make a few of their own.


After all, the goal isn't to have a dog who is brilliant at following instructions. It's to have a dog who is increasingly capable of managing themselves, even when we're not telling them what to do.

How Can I Help You?

I’m here to support you and your dog as you build a stronger, more confident, and more harmonious partnership. Whether you’d like to book a training session, ask a question, or explore how my services can help your canine companion thrive, I’m always happy to hear from you. I look forward to connecting with you and your dog.

Contact Linda Hams, Dog Behaviourist and Trainer